Common Craft Blog
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
By leelefever on May 03, 2004 - 11:34am
Updated: We have created a short (3:52) video called "Wikis in Plain English " that you might enjoy. It was inspired by the content of this post.
This entry should provide an easy-to-understand (but fictional) example of a wiki at work for people new to the technology/concept. While this use of a wiki may be unconventional, I think it provides a foundation for understanding how wikis can be used to accumulate and organize group information.
Background:
My friends and I are going on a camping trip in two weeks and we need to figure out who is bringing what. We plan to backpack, so redundancy should be avoided at all costs. Our goal is to make sure that every person brings their part of the whole.
Luckily, we are all computer users and are familiar with a wiki- which is a type of website that can be updated/edited without programming or special permissions. If you are unfamiliar with wikis, go here.
The Wiki:
I open the new wiki and like all new wikis, it starts as a blank slate- no content at all. Since I opened the wiki, I take the lead and start off by editing the front page by clicking the “Edit This Page†link. In plain text, I describe our goals, the dates and other logistics and click “Saveâ€. The front page of the wiki now has content that relates the basics of the trip.
Next, I edit the page and add two headings: “What We Have†and “What We Needâ€. To make the headings stand out, I use special punctuation like this “^^^What We Haveâ€. Under these headings, the whole group will use the wiki to figure out what we’ll be bringing on the trip.
I send an email to the group that says “Folks, I’ve opened a new wiki space for our camping trip. Please visit it and add what you will be bringing on the trip. Here’s the link: xxxxxxxx.comâ€
Accumulating Information:
Over the next two days, my camping buddies each visit the wiki and click the “Edit This Page†link to add what they will bring.
Josh edits the page and says he’ll bring a camp stove- but he has no fuel. So he puts the stove under the “Things We Have†column and the fuel under “Things We Need†column.
Soon after, Karen arrives at the wiki and sees that fuel is needed. Knowing that she can bring fuel, she moves the word “fuel†from the “Need†column to the “Have†column- ensuring that the group can feel secure that we have the fuel we need for the stove.
Jimmy has a camp stove and fuel, and planned to bring it, but once he visited the wiki, he saw that Karen and Josh have plans to bring theirs. So, he edits the wiki to show that he’ll bring cooler and ice. Then, he puts “beer†under the “things we need†column.
Over a few days, the group is able to finalize the list by viewing the wiki and making edits to the lists to reflect what they can bring. We can all see and agree on what we’ll bring and what is needed. We reach consensus on the wiki. If any one of us sees an inconsistency or mistake, we can correct it on behalf of the group.
More Than Camping Supplies:
It turns out that we don’t have a place to camp. So, I add a completely new page to the wiki so that we’ll have a blank slate for talking about campsites. I edit the front page and use special punctuation to add a new page. It looks like this when I type it in: [Choose Campsites]. Once I click “Save†and return to the wiki home page, I see that the phrase “Choose Campsites†is now a link. When I click it, a blank page appears with the heading “Choose Campsites.â€
So, just like I did on the home page, I edit the page to add content. I list my top 2 choices for campsites and ask the other campers to nominate their favorites by editing the “Choose Campsites†page. Over the next few days, they all come by and edit the page to add their nominations and talk about the benefits of each. In the end, we have a great list of sites and use the wiki to select the best one.
Re-Usable Information:
It turns out that the camping trip was a success- we all brought exactly what we needed and loved the campsite (though we wish Casey had not eaten the beans.)
A few months later, we plan another trip and find that the wiki we created before is still available and provides a perfect starting point for the planning. We have the supplies and campsites listed already, so the next trip is even better.
Conclusion:
Working together with a wiki, we were able to easily come to agreement on what we needed. Because we all have equal access and there are no technical barriers, everyone in the group could play an equal and essential role in the planning. We all agree that there was really no better way to plan the trip than through using the wiki.


Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Lee,
Good and as you say, unusual, illustration of the Wiki concept. 3 observations which you might want to comment on:
1. There is still a lack of an easy way to set up a wiki, in that with Typepad, setting up my blog was easy. There doesn't seem to be the equivalent for wikis.
2. You ideally want the twiki kind of wiki, where you can control access, otherwise people could maliciously or unintentionally muck about with your wiki.
3. You might want the facility to make it private, otherwise to would-be burglars, you are telling them all about when you won't be around.
Simon
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
I think you may good points Simon. I'm sure other would disagree, but I don't know of a wiki provider that makes wikis as easy for new users as TypePad does for weblogs; they are apples and oranges though. Can anyone make suggestions?
For this example, I would prefer a private wiki, like you say. In my mind, it's a little like online communities. People think of them as public by default, but I think private communities and wikis can serve small groups very effectively and cut down on the noise.
Never thought about the burglars. Funny.
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Lee,
Yes, more private services for Wiki's (and for that matter, blogs) would be great.
Eg for a family, it would be cool to have a kind of wiki calender, ie an online calendar, but that had the wiki concept, so everyone in the family could contribute. Then have an 'invited-in' process for your trip idea, so that people outside the family could edit just those related pages.
Have to think about who pays for the wiki-space though...
Simon
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
The crazy thing is I just did this yesterday. What are the odds of that. I'd post the URL but I don't want the wiki to be taken over, the camping trip isn't for another two weeks and we still have planning to do.
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Paul,
Understand your reticence on the URL, but let us know in your blog, or here, how you got on with the wiki.
Simon
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
What are the chances Paul? That's crazy. I'd be interested in hearing the synopsis after the trip- how did the wiki work? Perhaps you could share the wiki after the trip? Just a thought... Thanks for commenting...
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Playing with access control is an unnecessary pain in the ass. Suppose next trip you want to invite someone new? Now you'll have to figure out how to add Jill to the access list. Or, if you have a password, you'll have to dig that password up again.
A password is only a string of characters that only some people know. A URL is the same thing. As you say, you are reticent to give away the URL to the wiki in the same way you'd be reticent to give away the password to the wiki. An obscure URL and a password is twice the work.
Therefore, just make the URL to the wiki obscure and then don't publish it. Don't waste time with additional access control.
P.S. http://seedwiki.com is an excellent free wiki host.
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Thanks Lee for this very nice article I just translated and adapted a bit towards a french audience who could be interested in organizing a party while walking :)
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
Seedwiki isn't free (after 120 days at least). swiki.net *is* free but doesn't seem to be answering at the moment. You might provide links to guides to Wiki syntax like this one:
http://www.wikiworld.com/wiki/index.php/NewbieHelp though there are many flavours of wiki each with its own syntax.
P.S. Do you know of any free way to implement the "subscribe to this comment" feature through an addon to Moveable Type?
Wiki and the Perfect Camping Trip
== [[nigritude ultramarine|http://forums.merkey.net]] ==
The ultimate [[http://forums.merkey.net Nigritude Ultramarine]] shall beat the other
[http://forums.merkey.net | Nigritude Ultramarine] that was made by
Nigritude Ultramarine Philipp Lenssen. Sorry Phil. :P mnuwsb.
== [[nigritude ultramarine|http://forums.merkey.net]] ==
The ultimate [[http://forums.merkey.net Nigritude Ultramarine]] shall beat the other
[http://forums.merkey.net | Nigritude Ultramarine] that was made by
Nigritude Ultramarine Philipp Lenssen. Sorry Phil. :P mnuwsb.
== [[nigritude ultramarine|http://forums.merkey.net]] ==
The ultimate [[http://forums.merkey.net Nigritude Ultramarine]] shall beat the other
[http://forums.merkey.net | Nigritude Ultramarine] that was made by
Nigritude Ultramarine Philipp Lenssen. Sorry Phil. :P mnuwsb.
== [[nigritude ultramarine|http://forums.merkey.net]] ==
The ultimate [[http://forums.merkey.net Nigritude Ultramarine]] shall beat the other
[http://forums.merkey.net | Nigritude Ultramarine] that was made by
Nigritude Ultramarine Philipp Lenssen. Sorry Phil. :P mnuwsb.
Spamming by uphu
Wikis Described in Plain English
Submitted by xtof (not verified) on May 9, 2004 - 1:49am.
Hi Lee, merci beaucoup. I just used your content to begin a french translation dropped here and now adapted with our french sauce :) If you see any trouble just delete the page. Source page will be maintained with a link on CommonCraft. Kind regards Will suscribe to your Rss feed.
Good network of Warcraft gold coin transactions, (wow gold) are cheap Lutheran guaranteed! wow gold Welcome to the site to see the price (World of Warcraft gold)wow power leveling